PARIS (Reuters) – The coronavirus will accelerate a Darwinian shakeout in Europe’s overcrowded airline industry that ultimately benefits Ryanair and British Airways owner IAG, industry experts predict.
People wearing protective masks walk in Malpensa airport near Milan, Italy, March 9, 2020. REUTERS/Flavio Lo Scalzo
Nobody is exempt from the short-term pain that has already seen Flybe collapse and Norwegian Air stock lose about 70% of its value in a month, with no end to the crisis in sight.
But the extreme stress-test already promises to increase the power of a handful of key players, when the epidemic eventually recedes and passengers return en masse.
“It’s inevitable in the next couple of weeks we’ll see more failures,” Ryanair Chief Executive Michael O’Leary said in a recent interview, citing Flybe and Norwegian as vulnerable.
Within days, the British regional carrier had ceased operations, blaming the virus outbreak for a sudden cash drain, and Norwegian scrapped 2020 guidance.
Norwegian did not respond to O’Leary’s comments. However, the company – which raised cash from shareholders in November for the third time in less than two years – has been cutting costs and unprofitable routes, as well as selling assets, to bolster its finances.
Whereas four airlines now control 80% of the U.S. market, Europe remains fragmented, with governments, unions and bilateral agreements impeding tie-ups. Consolidation happens when airlines grab routes and traffic from bankrupt rivals.
Flybe’s demise reduces price competition on routes it shared with Ryanair and easyJet, just as a Norwegian exit would support competitors’ fares and traffic.
“This virus will expedite the thesis of consolidation, possibly to extreme levels,” Citi analyst Mark Manduca said, adding that 35% of Europe’s short-haul market was loss-making in 2019.
For investors who still want airlines, Manduca added, “we recommend sticking with the well-capitalized names who in 2021 should be able to consolidate the market: Ryanair and IAG.”
The virus’s spread is hitting more routes – prompting a 50% Lufthansa capacity cut and similar moves by others – while the full traffic impact is yet to show up in published data.
International bookings to Europe plunged 79% as the outbreak mushroomed in Italy, leaving no doubt that the slump will be worse than the 2003 SARS epidemic. It may wipe $113 billion off airlines’ revenues, according to IATA, their global association.
(GRAPHIC: European airlines hit by coronavirus – here)
Airline executives still cling to the hope of a “V-shaped” rebound, mirroring SARS. Those with robust balance sheets can plan for the time when demand comes roaring back.
A three-month shutdown would inflate Air France-KLM’s net debt to 7.7 times earnings, Citi calculates, and swell Lufthansa’s multiple to 12.4.
But Ryanair’s leverage would remain at a relatively manageable 1.2, easyJet’s at 1.9 and IAG’s at 3.5.
Ryanair’s growth has been hampered by the grounding of Boeing’s 737 MAX aircraft – it has 135 on order – and sold-out production of the Airbus A321neo it is eyeing for Austrian subsidiary Laudamotion.
But CEO O’Leary believes the crisis may bring aircraft deals as stressed customers relinquish delivery slots, and stands ready to place orders “today, tomorrow, next week” if the price is right, he said at a March 3 event in Brussels.
The MAX grounding, after two deadly crashes, has cushioned Ryanair against a downturn by leaving fewer seats to fill, O’Leary acknowledged. But, with an eye on the long term, “I would prefer not to be cushioned,” he added.
Mid-sized carriers such as Portugal’s TAP, Alitalia and SAS are “not in a great leverage situation” and could succumb, Bernstein analyst Daniel Roeska said.
Sweden’s SAS is taking “strong measures” to rein in costs with reduced timetables, temporary layoffs and a hiring freeze, a spokeswoman said. TAP, which was partially privatized in 2015, said recent cost-cutting and debt rescheduling would allow “better management of its treasury position”.
Alitalia, which has received 1.3 billion euros ($1.5 billion) in state loans since filing for bankruptcy in 2017, suspended most of its Milan operations on Sunday as the government locked down large areas of northern Italy. The company did not address questions about its liquidity situation.
Among airlines whose failure could drive consolidation, “the most meaningful would be Norwegian,” Bernstein’s Roeska said, citing its large network and overlap with rivals.
“It’s not guaranteed they have to go bust,” he said, with much depending on planned asset sales. “It’s still unclear to us how long they have cash for.”
(GRAPHIC: Europe’s airlines and debt – here)
Even if the crisis threatens larger airlines, few would expect an Air France-KLM or a Lufthansa to be allowed to fail by their governments. But large carriers are warning against state support for smaller rivals.
“There were airlines who were looking for state aid before this happened,” said outgoing IAG boss Willie Walsh, who cleared European regulatory hurdles to merge BA with Iberia in 2011 before adding Vueling, Aer Lingus and Air Europa.
“I don’t believe this is an excuse for those weaker airlines to demand state aid,” Walsh said.
The slump may rattle Air France-KLM, as new CEO Ben Smith pursues a costly fleet renewal to cut operating expenses and improve the group’s trailing profitability.
Business bookings have been hit, Smith told Reuters, but Asia may be bottoming out and some China services could soon resume. “We’re looking every week at when we’ll start returning,” he said.
Privately, however, other executives at the Franco-Dutch group expressed concern.
Its weaker margins make Air France-KLM more fragile than major peers, said one. “I don’t see any silver linings.”
Reporting by Laurence Frost; Additional reporting by Tim Hepher in Paris and Victoria Klesty in Oslo; Editing by Mark Potter and Edward Tobin